Treasure Island MGM+
39 stories Updated for U.S. readers
Why Some Call David Oyelowo’s Accent the Best Part of Treasure Island
David Oyelowo’s Jamaican-inflected Long John Silver stands out in Treasure Island. Explore the actor’s approach and what critics have said.
Treasure Island 2026: Is the Hispaniola Cook Reveal Brilliant or Predictable?
Treasure Island Episode 1 ends with Long John Silver revealed as the Hispaniola’s new cook. Here’s why the twist works, what remains unex...
Treasure Island vs Black Sails: Which Pirate Series Feels More Authentic?
Treasure Island (2026) vs Black Sails: compare story, Long John Silver, historical realism, production design, reviews, and which pirate ...
Treasure Island Production Design: Stunning Visuals, Weak Script?
The 2026 Treasure Island adaptation pairs atmospheric ships, period costumes and striking coastal imagery with a script that has divided ...
Why Book Purists Are Rejecting the New Treasure Island Adaptation
Why the 2026 Treasure Island adaptation has divided book-first viewers: Jim Hawkins’s photographic memory, Bess Hawkins’s expanded role, ...
The Scene Behind The Guardian’s Treasure Island Takedown: What the Review Actually Criticized
The Guardian’s October 12, 2026 review gave Treasure Island two stars, but it did not identify one single scene as the reason for its ver...
Will Negative Reviews Kill Treasure Island’s Momentum Before Episode 2?
The Guardian and other critics have questioned MGM+’s new Treasure Island adaptation. Here’s why early reviews may slow momentum—but cann...
Treasure Island’s Race and History Debate: What the 2026 Series Gets Right—and Where Critics Disagree
David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver and Hayley Atwell’s expanded Bess Hawkins put race, colonial history, and gender at the center of the 20...
Long John Silver’s Parrot in Treasure Island: Clever Detail or Lazy Cliché?
Does Long John Silver’s parrot add personality to Treasure Island (2026), or is it a pirate cliché? We examine the official imagery, The ...
Why the Admiral Benbow Opening Feels More Like a Soap Opera Than Adventure
The opening of MGM+’s 2026 Treasure Island puts family tension, flirtation and a dangerous treasure map ahead of straightforward swashbuc...
Is Treasure Island Too Modern for a Classic Pirate Tale? Critics Clash
The Guardian’s two-star review questions whether the 2026 Treasure Island adaptation’s new memory twist, expanded Bess Hawkins and height...
Treasure Island MGM+ vs. the Book: 5 Major Changes Fans Are Debating
How does MGM+’s 2026 Treasure Island compare with Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel? We break down five major changes, from Bess Hawkins’ ex...
The Biggest Complaint on X About David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver? What Early Reactions Actually Show
David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver is one of the most discussed elements of the 2026 Treasure Island adaptation. Here is what the first rev...
Paramount+ UK Premiere Day: First Reactions to Treasure Island
Treasure Island arrives on Paramount+ UK with sharply divided early reviews. Here is what The Guardian and Radio Times say, how the cast ...
Why Some Viewers Are Already Calling the New Treasure Island Unwatchable
Early reviews of Treasure Island (2026) are sharply divided over its changes to Jim Hawkins, Bess Hawkins and the classic pirate adventur...
Silver’s Jamaican Accent Controversy: Why It’s Sparking Debate Already
David Oyelowo’s Jamaican-accented Long John Silver is a bold reinterpretation in MGM+’s Treasure Island. Here’s what early reviews actual...
Early Rotten Tomatoes Score: What the First Four Critic Reviews Actually Say
Treasure Island (2026) has no Rotten Tomatoes critic score yet as of October 12, 2026. Here’s what the first published reviews say about ...
Treasure Island Episode 1 Recap: Every Major Change From the Original Book
MGM+’s Treasure Island premiere reshapes Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic with Jim Hawkins’ photographic memory, a more active Bess, an e...
Metacritic Score Breakdown: Why Treasure Island Is Sitting at Mixed Reviews Right Now
Is MGM+’s Treasure Island really sitting at a mixed Metacritic score? Here’s what the current aggregator listings and early reviews actua...
David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver Performance: The One Thing Every Review Agrees On
Critics may disagree about MGM+’s Treasure Island, but several early reviews single out David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver for his charisma...
Early Reviews Are In: Why Critics Call Treasure Island “Handsome but Undercooked”
Early Treasure Island reviews praise David Oyelowo’s Long John Silver and the series’ visual ambition but question its storytelling, expa...
Treasure Island MGM+ Episode 1 Ending Twist: Why Silver Is Already on the Hispaniola
Why is Long John Silver already aboard the Hispaniola at the end of Treasure Island Episode 1? Jim’s photographic memory and Bess’s decis...
The One Scene in Episode 1 That Could Make Treasure Island an Instant Classic (or Instant Skip)
The biggest cliffhanger in Treasure Island Episode 1 puts Long John Silver aboard the Hispaniola with Jim and Bess. Here’s why the reveal...
Comparison: 1950 Disney Treasure Island vs 2026 MGM+ Version Side-by-Side
A side-by-side comparison of Disney’s 1950 Treasure Island and MGM+’s 2026 series, covering Long John Silver, Jim Hawkins, Bess Hawkins, ...
Page 1 of 2 · 39 articles