Updated October 20, 2026 · By Shivam Das
Quick answer: There is no verified, developer-published trade-value list proving that a specific Steal An Egg Halloween pet has already dropped in value. The clearest early risk is oversupply: common outcomes from the repeatable Halloween Dimension Egg—especially Candy Corn and Hollow Bat—can lose trade leverage as more players hatch them. Rare outcomes such as Soul Phantom, rare biome pets, and Zombified Robux-egg variants may be better positioned, but that is a market-risk assessment, not a guaranteed price forecast.
If you are deciding whether to trade, keep, or hatch a Halloween pet, do not treat rarity labels or social-media “value lists” as proof of what players will actually offer. This guide separates confirmed game mechanics from early community signals so you can avoid panic trades.
What “dropping in value” actually means in Steal An Egg
Steal An Egg does not have one official, fixed player-to-player price sheet. Community trackers often measure pets by in-game income per second, while players may value limited pets for rarity, appearance, collection completion, or future demand. Those are different markets. A pet can be weak for income but desirable to collectors—or powerful in-game but easy to find and therefore less exciting in a trade.
As of October 20, the most useful warning is that Halloween Update 9 is still new. A reliable, long-term price history for its newest pets is not yet available. Some third-party indexes explicitly say that income data for new Halloween pets has not been confirmed. That means claims such as “this pet lost 40% of its value overnight” should be treated as unverified unless the poster shows comparable trades, dates, and the pet’s mutation and weight.
Halloween pets with the biggest early downside risk
| Pet or group | What is confirmed | Early value outlook |
|---|---|---|
| Candy Corn (pet) | The Halloween Dimension Egg lists it as a 51% outcome. | Higher oversupply risk. Frequent hatches can make it less distinctive in trades. This is not proof that its price has already fallen. |
| Hollow Bat | The same egg lists a 24% chance. | Moderate-to-high supply risk. It is much more common than the 6.5% and 0.5% outcomes, so sellers may compete on offers. |
| Scarecrow | The same egg lists an 18% chance. | Moderate risk. Supply is lower than Candy Corn or Hollow Bat, but rarity alone cannot guarantee demand. |
| Pumpkin Golem | The same egg lists a 6.5% chance and labels it Secret. | Potentially more resilient, not guaranteed. Watch completed trades and whether players still seek it after the launch rush. |
| Soul Phantom | The same egg lists a 0.5% chance and labels it Eternal. | Scarcity advantage, with a liquidity caveat. Rare pets can attract attention, but a low chance does not automatically create a high offer if few traders want it. |
| Common biome pets | Update 9 added 18 pets across three Halloween Dimension biomes. | Watch the most frequently found pets. Easier-to-obtain pets can become less special as players finish collecting the event set. |
| Zombified Halloween Egg variants | Third-party launch guides report a separate 1% Zombified roll in the Robux Halloween Egg; check the live in-game shop. | Potential collector demand, but higher spending risk. Do not buy Robux eggs solely because a seller predicts future value. |
Why the common Halloween pets may be losing their “new pet” premium
At launch, players often pay extra for novelty. That premium can fade when the same egg is available to the entire player base and more copies enter circulation. The Halloween Dimension Egg costs 2,250 Candy Corn and lists five outcomes: Candy Corn (51%), Hollow Bat (24%), Scarecrow (18%), Pumpkin Golem (6.5%), and Soul Phantom (0.5%). The displayed odds total 100%.
Those odds make a useful supply comparison. Candy Corn and Hollow Bat are much more likely to appear than Soul Phantom. If many players open the egg repeatedly, common outcomes can flood informal trade channels. But probability is not a live market price: players can still want a common pet for a collection, a mutation, or a particular size.
Important: the Candy Corn pet is not the same thing as Candy Corn currency. Currency is used to buy the egg; the pet is one possible hatch. Make sure any trade discussion is referring to the pet rather than your event-currency balance.
Which pets look better positioned to hold value?
There is no guaranteed “safe” Halloween pet. Still, a few factors can support demand over time:
- Low supply: the 0.5% Soul Phantom outcome and rare biome spawns are harder to obtain than common egg results, based on the reported in-game odds or community spawn tracking.
- Distinct variants: a rare mutation or Zombified version may be more desirable than a standard version of the same pet. Always compare like with like.
- Collector demand: pets that players need to complete an index may stay in demand, but that demand can change when new content arrives.
- Limited availability: an event pet may become harder to obtain after the event ends—but only if it actually stops dropping and is not reintroduced later.
Update 9 has been described by community guides as a two-part Halloween event. That matters because a second part could change what players want, add competing pets, or affect the perceived value of saved currency. Do not assume today’s rarest pet will remain the rarest after the next update.
How to check whether a pet is truly falling in value
- Compare recent completed trades, not asking prices. A player listing a pet for an ambitious offer does not prove someone accepted it.
- Match the exact version. Compare the same pet, mutation, weight/size, and variant. A Rainbow or Zombified pet should not be compared with a standard one.
- Check more than one community source. Value lists can disagree or lag behind updates. Look for timestamps and evidence rather than a confident number.
- Watch supply and demand separately. More copies appearing can pressure offers, but a pet may retain demand if collectors still need it.
- Avoid panic-selling after one bad offer. One low offer is not a trend. If you do not need the slot or currency immediately, wait for more evidence.
- Never send first in a risky “trade.” Community guides warn that some exchanges happen through separate gifts rather than a protected trade window. Only exchange with trusted players and do not share account credentials.
Should you sell, keep, or hatch your Halloween pets?
- Sell or trade common duplicates if you have no collection goal for them and receive a fair, verifiable offer. Do not accept a rushed trade just because someone says the pet is “crashing.”
- Keep one copy for your index if collection completion matters to you. The value of a completed collection may be more useful to your playstyle than a speculative trade.
- Think carefully before spending Robux. The rarest outcome is not guaranteed, and probability does not promise a result after a set number of openings. Treat paid eggs as entertainment spending, not an investment.
- Save evidence. Screenshot the current in-game odds and note the date when comparing offers. That makes it easier to spot real changes after an update.
For a practical event plan, see our Steal An Egg Candy Corn farming route, our Part 2 prediction breakdown, and our guide to Abandoned Manor secrets.
Frequently asked questions
Which Steal An Egg Halloween pet is dropping in value right now?
There is no independently verified price history confirming a specific drop as of October 20, 2026. Common outcomes such as Candy Corn and Hollow Bat face the greatest oversupply risk because their displayed hatch chances are higher, but that is a risk assessment—not proof of a measured decline.
What is the rarest pet in the Halloween Dimension Egg?
The in-game odds reported for the egg list Soul Phantom at 0.5%, the lowest chance among its five outcomes. The odds can be checked in the live shop, and a low hatch chance does not guarantee a particular trade offer.
Does a Secret or Eternal rarity guarantee high trade value?
No. Rarity can limit supply, but actual value also depends on demand, availability, mutations, size, and what players are willing to exchange. Do not treat rarity labels as fixed prices.
Are Halloween pets a good investment?
They are collectibles in a changing game economy, not guaranteed investments. Event timing, new updates, and player interest can all change demand. Avoid spending Robux or trading valuable pets based only on a prediction.
How can I avoid a fake pet-value list?
Look for dated evidence, comparable pet variants, recent completed trades, and multiple sources. Be suspicious of guaranteed-price claims, free-pet generators, scripts, or anyone asking for your password or account code.
Sources and verification notes
- Timesaver.gg: Steal An Egg Halloween Pets and Update 9 guide — launch details and reported egg odds; third-party guide, not an official trade-value list.
- STEAL EGG: Halloween Dimension Egg chances — reported price and outcomes.
- OofWiki: Steal An Egg values — community value methodology; it notes that official fixed values are not published and that new Halloween pet income figures may be unavailable.
Editorial note: This article distinguishes confirmed in-game odds from community estimates. Recheck the shop and current player trades after each update; values and availability can change quickly.
