Published October 9, 2026 | By Shivam Das
Haunted Hotel Season 2 has an early positive review from But Why Tho?: critic LaNeysha Campbell gives the Netflix animated horror-comedy 8.5 out of 10. Rotten Tomatoes’ Season 2 page currently lists three critic reviews, making this an early snapshot—not a settled verdict on the season or a reliable measure of audience opinion.
The distinction matters. An individual critic’s 8.5/10 rating is not the same thing as Rotten Tomatoes’ percentage-based Tomatometer. The page lists Campbell’s rating alongside reviews from Tessa Smith at Mama’s Geeky and Tania Hussain at Collider. Readers should check the live page for changes as more reviews arrive.
What does But Why Tho’s 8.5/10 actually mean?
Campbell describes Season 2 as a steady continuation that builds on the first season while developing its characters further. Her review highlights the series’ mix of adult comedy, supernatural chaos, horror references and more emotionally grounded character work. The score is a strong recommendation from one critic, but it should be read alongside the review itself rather than treated as a universal audience consensus.
One of the review’s notable points is the way the show balances absurd supernatural situations with character consequences. The Undervale Hotel remains a place for bizarre scares and fast jokes, but the new season also spends more time with the people—and ghosts—living through those situations. That balance is central to why the series can feel both silly and unexpectedly sincere.
Rotten Tomatoes has three critic reviews so far
At the time of checking on October 9, Rotten Tomatoes lists three Season 2 critic reviews: Campbell’s 8.5/10 for But Why Tho?, Tessa Smith’s review for Mama’s Geeky, and Tania Hussain’s 8/10 for Collider. Rotten Tomatoes’ listing says Smith praised the season for adding lore without losing what worked in Season 1. Hussain’s quoted assessment points to sharp jokes, inventive scares and moments with emotional impact.
That is an encouraging opening set of notices, but three reviews are still a small sample. Review counts and displayed scores can change as more outlets publish. The page also reports fewer than 50 audience ratings at this snapshot, so it would be premature to describe the audience response as settled.
Why the review’s character focus matters
Campbell’s review also singles out the season’s character development, particularly Nathan’s more complicated emotional journey. The show’s cheerful surface does not erase the harder feelings underneath, and that contrast gives the comedy more weight than a string of unrelated spooky gags would have. The review also notes that the newly introduced Shayna becomes less prominent later in the season, a reminder that not every new addition receives equal room to grow.
That character-first approach is a useful lens for viewers deciding whether to start Season 2. The appeal is not only the monster designs or horror references; it is the contrast between a chaotic workplace, a supernatural family and occasional moments of genuine vulnerability.
Watch the official Season 2 trailer
Netflix’s official trailer gives viewers a direct preview of the new season. The video below is hosted by Netflix on YouTube.
Where to read the reviews
- Read LaNeysha Campbell’s full review at But Why Tho?
- Check the live Rotten Tomatoes Season 2 page
- Read Tessa Smith’s review at Mama’s Geeky
- Visit Haunted Hotel on Netflix
Frequently asked questions
What score did But Why Tho give Haunted Hotel Season 2?
LaNeysha Campbell rated Season 2 8.5/10 in her But Why Tho? review published October 9, 2026.
How many critic reviews does Rotten Tomatoes list for Season 2?
The Rotten Tomatoes Season 2 page listed three critic reviews when checked on October 9, 2026. The count may change as new reviews are added.
Does an 8.5/10 review mean the Tomatometer is 85%?
No. An individual critic’s 8.5/10 score is a separate rating. Rotten Tomatoes’ Tomatometer is a percentage based on qualifying critic reviews, so readers should consult the live page for the current displayed score and review count.
Is Haunted Hotel Season 2 streaming now?
Yes. Netflix lists Haunted Hotel and its second season on the official title page.
Bottom line: But Why Tho’s 8.5/10 is a strong early endorsement of Haunted Hotel Season 2, while Rotten Tomatoes’ three-review snapshot is still too small to call the final critical consensus. The most useful next step is to read the full review and revisit the live score as coverage grows.
Image note: the images in this article are credited to their linked publishers. They are not represented as social-media posts. A verified LaNeysha Campbell X/Instagram post directly about this review was not confirmed, so no fabricated social post embed has been added.
